Responses will vary based on an individuals cultural upbringing ideology and educational knowledge; however you must support your position with appropriate theory and principle.In Clinical Ethics three clinical ethicists (a philosopher -Jonsen a physician -Siegler and a lawyer -Winslade) developed a method to work through difficult cases. The process can be thought of as the ethics workup similar to the History and Physical skills that all medical students use when learning how to workup a patient’s primary complaints. While this method has deep philosophical roots clinicians who use this method like the way it parallels the way they think through tough medical cases.Medical Indications- All clinical encounters include a diagnosis prognosis and treatment options and include an assessment of goals of carePatient Preferences- The patients preferences and values are central in determining the best and most respectful course of treatment.Quality of Life- The objective of all clinical encounters is to improve or at least address quality of life for the patient as experienced by the patient.Contextual Features- All clinical encounters occur in a wider social context beyond physician and patient to include family the law culture hospital policy insurance companies and other financial issues and so forth.Scenario 1At your last office staff meeting the rising cost of rent and overhead was discussed. One of your partners mentioned that he had been approached by a large pharmacy chain with an offer of space adjacent to their new pharmacy that is only one block from your current offices. The cost per square foot is half of what you are currently paying and there was a suggestion that the rent could be lowered if the volume of prescriptions from your office were substantial. Although this offer is very tempting you have reservations about the potential conflict of interest. One of your partners is pushing to explore this option. You are wondering if you could manage the conflict by refusing to engage in any reduction in rent based on prescription volume but still take the space at the reduced lease costs. Another partner feels that this arrangement will compromise her autonomy and feels that it will look as if the office is associated with the pharmacy even if it is not. Everyone agrees that the overhead costs need to be reduced. What is the right thing to do?Scenario 2You are the training director for a residency program. Recently several residents have come to you reporting that a physician frequently makes disparaging comments to residents and to patients about the work of other physicians. The physicians latest comment was to a patient in which he said he would not allow a particular physician to treat his pets. Other comments attributed to this physician involved telling the residents that a surgeon is a butcher and a psychiatrist a mindless twit. The residents have attempted to speak to him about this practice to which the physician responded by saying he only speaks the truth adding that patients and residents have a right to know. The residents report the comments appear to be unwarranted and they seem to be scaring the patients. Is this physician behaving unethically? Should physicians question the work of their colleagues? How should this be done?Scenario 3You are nearing the end of your practice career and many of your patients are older. Several of them have developed mild dementia and youve been discussing their wishes should they continue to lose mental capacity. The other day an elderly gentleman arrived for his appointment with his middle-aged son who reported that his father is becoming increasingly forgetful. The son would like to have his father moved to a facility rather than continue to live on his own. While examining your patient you note he has multiple bruises on his upper arms that suggest he has been grabbed by someones hand. When you discuss with him the idea of moving to an assisted living facility he becomes very upset and says his son wants to get his hands on his money and that is why he wants him to move from his own home. The patients Mini Mental Status examination is within the normal limits and he reports that his multiple bruises are the result of a friend grabbing his arm while they were out walking. You would like to respect your patients autonomy to make his own decisions but have some concerns that he may be at risk. You are not sure what the ethical principles are and approach your colleague for advice. What advice would you give to this colleague if you were approached?Scenario 4You have been treating a 24-year-old man for many years in your family practice. He has an anxiety disorder and had some trouble with substance abuse in his teens but has been doing well and attending university. After his last visit for a minor injury you noted that a prescription pad was missing. A few weeks later you received a call from a pharmacy asking you to verify a prescription for Lorazepam 1mg bid 300 tablets and acetaminophen with codeine 300 tabs written for this patient. You report that this is a forgery and ask the pharmacy not to fill it. Your colleague urges you to report this to the police and states this is allowed under the Health Information Act. You are very angry with the betrayal of trust with your patient but you have never reported a patient to the police and wonder what you should do. The CMA code of ethics advises you to keep patients personal health information private and only consent to release to a third party with consent or as provided for by the law such as when the maintenance of confidentiality would result in a significant risk of substantial harm. You are wondering if your patient has a substance abuse problem and whether he could be selling this medication. You have called the patient to come in
The post Carefully read each scenario describing an ethical dilemma in health care.Directions: Carefully read each scenario describing an ethical dilemma in health care. SelectTWOscenarios for which you will write a thorough response to not exceedONEcomplete paragraph for each. appeared first on Nursing Homework Help.